. as well as any padding scheme used on the messages. If the decisional DiffieHellman assumption (DDH) holds in Our systems do not have, and we need to build in, what David Gelernter called topsight, the ability to not only create technological solutions but also see and explore their consequences before we build business models, companies and markets on their strengths, and especially on their limitations., Chudakov added that this is especially necessary because in the next decade and beyond, By expanding collection and analysis of data and the resulting application of this information, a layer of intelligence or thinking manipulation is added to processes and objects that previously did not have that layer. It is unclear how the proposed algorithms address these well-known problems, given that they are often subject to no regulations whatsoever. How is anyone to know how his/her data is being massaged and for what purposes to justify what ends? The two themes are advanced in these answers: Justin Reich, executive director at the MIT Teaching Systems Lab, observed, The algorithms will be primarily designed by white and Asian men with data selected by these same privileged actors for the benefit of consumers like themselves. FALSE. Two illustrative answers: Ryan Hayes, owner of Fit to Tweet, commented, Twenty years ago we talked about the digital divide being people who had access to a computer at home vs. those that didnt, or those who had access to the internet vs. those who didnt . ) The security strength of El Gamal is based on the hardness of solving discrete logarithms, which was first proposed in 1985 by ElGamal (1985). For what kind of usage should we prefer using Diffie-Hellman in order to exchange keys instead of ElGamal, and most important why should we use one or the other? Ultimately, most key decisions will be political, and Im optimistic that a general trend toward positive outcomes will prevail, given the tremendous potential upside to technology use. This makes it secure against attacks from hackers. In the next section we offer a brief outline of seven key themes found among the written elaborations. It has the advantage the same plaintext gives a different ciphertext (with near certainty) each time it is encrypted. Cryptography ElGamal Abstract . In general, the El -Gamal algorithm is used to encrypt messages. Its an urgent, global cause with committed and mobilized experts looking for support., Eventually, software liability law will be recognized to be in need of reform, since right now, literally, coders can get away with murder., The Law of Unintended Consequences indicates that the increasing layers of societal and technical complexity encoded in algorithms ensure that unforeseen catastrophic events will occur probably not the ones we were worrying about., Eventually we will evolve mechanisms to give consumers greater control that should result in greater understanding and trust . It consists of both encryption and signature algorithms. , one can easily construct a valid encryption The only one I found is that a known-plain text attack is possible in ElGamal if the same $r$ is used twice during encryption. If this is an advantage or a disadvantage depends on your requirements. Following is a brief collection of comments by several of the many top analysts who participated in this canvassing: Vinton Cerf, Internet Hall of Fame member and vice president and chief internet evangelist at Google: Algorithms are mostly intended to steer people to useful information and I see this as a net positive., Cory Doctorow, writer, computer science activist-in-residence at MIT Media Lab and co-owner of Boing Boing, responded, The choices in this question are too limited. ElGamal encryption, when the paramters are chosen in the right way achieves the weaker notion of indistinguishability under chosen plaintext attacks (IND-CPA), where IES/ECIES achieves stronger security, namely indistinguishability under chosen ciphertext attacks (IND-CCA). They also noted that those who create and evolve algorithms are not held accountable to society and argued there should be some method by which they are. ) What are the advantages of neural cryptography over Diffie-Hellman algorithm? The code above has the right-to-left method with modular reductions at each step. Do the human beings the data points reflect even know or did they just agree to the terms of service because they had no real choice? This will change. As the overall cost of health care declines, it becomes increasingly feasible to provide single-payer health insurance for the entire population, which has known beneficial health outcomes and efficiencies. That dehumanization has now spread to our health care and social services. Representative comments: Susan Etlinger, industry analyst at Altimeter Group, said, Much like the way we increasingly wish to know the place and under what conditions our food and clothing are made, we should question how our data and decisions are made as well. 2 The patients need to integrate and manage their medical data . Lets proceed and see how we can implement the same using Python programming language. El-Gamal is one of the popular cryptographic algorithms. TRUE B. We need to confront the reality that power and authority are moving from people to machines. Computer code is algorithmic. Downsides: 1) Weak security proof (DDH) 2) Annoying to implement, since you need to be able to encode as group elements 3) malleable 4) The limited message size means that you typically still need to implement hybrid encryption. Mike Sipser and Wikipedia seem to disagree on Chomsky's normal form, YA scifi novel where kids escape a boarding school, in a hollowed out asteroid. ElGamal has the disadvantage that the ciphertext is twice as long as the plaintext. advantages, limitation and further extensions of the system. With the help of cryptography, the employee can communicate securely. as follows: Like most public key systems, the ElGamal cryptosystem is usually used as part of a hybrid cryptosystem, where the message itself is encrypted using a symmetric cryptosystem, and ElGamal is then used to encrypt only the symmetric key. Alice's ElGamal private [ decryption] key is ( p, r, ). Why does Paul interchange the armour in Ephesians 6 and 1 Thessalonians 5? Some advantages of XTR are its fast key generation (much faster than RSA), small key sizes (much smaller than RSA, comparable with ECC for . These findings do not represent all the points of view that are possible to a question like this, but they do reveal a wide range of valuable observations based on current trends. ( Predictive sentencing scoring contractors to Americas prison system use machine learning to optimize sentencing recommendation. ElGamal encryption The classical ElGamal public-key encryption scheme [12] readily extends to any group G wherein computing discrete logarithms is as-sumed to be intractable. 2 It is a subsidiary of The Pew Charitable Trusts. To illuminate current attitudes about the potential impacts of algorithms in the next decade, Pew Research Center and Elon Universitys Imagining the Internet Center conducted a large-scale canvassing of technology experts, scholars, corporate practitioners and government leaders. But when one wants to use such a hybrid encryption scheme IES/ECIES is a better choice. "ElGamal" redirects here. She has a great passion for developing web applications and configuring networks. If we mandate, or establish normative limits, on practices that correct this sleazy conduct, then we can use empiricism to correct for bias and improve the fairness and impartiality of firms and the state (and public/private partnerships). The systems should be interactive, so that people can examine how changing data, assumptions, rules would change outcomes. RSA algorithm (Rivest-Shamir-Adleman): RSA is a cryptosystem for public-key encryption , and is widely used for securing sensitive data, particularly when being sent over an insecure network such as the Internet . Public key encryption is an attempt to curb the following problems faced by symmetric encryption: Key distribution under symmetric encryption requires that either: If the use of cryptography were to become widespread, not just in military situations, but for commercial and private purposes, then electronic messages and documents would need the equivalent of signatures used in paper documents. Every step in an algorithm has its own logical sequence so it is easy to debug. How can I drop 15 V down to 3.7 V to drive a motor? To remove the mask, a clue is given in form of gk. A representative statement of this view came from Barry Chudakov, founder and principal at Sertain Research and StreamFuzion Corp. Algorithms help gadgets respond to voice commands, recognize faces, sort photos and build and drive cars. Thanks for contributing an answer to Cryptography Stack Exchange! A number of participants in this canvassing expressed concerns over the change in the publics information diets, the atomization of media, an over-emphasis of the extreme, ugly, weird news, and the favoring of truthiness over more-factual material that may be vital to understanding how to be a responsible citizen of the world. Or are you comparing it to something specific ? {\displaystyle G} %PDF-1.5 Strength.An assessment of the strength of the algorithm, based on key length, algorithm complexity and the best methods of attack. Even datasets with billions of pieces of information do not capture the fullness of peoples lives and the diversity of their experiences. Well need both industry reform within the technology companies creating these systems and far more savvy regulatory regimes to handle the complex challenges that arise., John Markoff, author of Machines of Loving Grace: The Quest for Common Ground Between Humans and Robots and senior writer at The New York Times, observed, I am most concerned about the lack of algorithmic transparency. G The Common Good has become a discredited, obsolete relic of The Past., In an economy increasingly dominated by a tiny, very privileged and insulated portion of the population, it will largely reproduce inequality for their benefit. See, for instance, [14, 4, 5]. It will be a net negative for society. An algorithm uses a definite procedure. \oM`Cu~/](O+J87O'~z}^{fQnx l_C This includes many of the daily (and often unpleasant) interactions we have with government today, from traffic offenses, manifestation of civil discontent, unfair treatment in commercial and legal processes, and the like. At minimum, institutions that have broad societal impact would need to disclose the input variables used, how they influence the outcome and be subject to review, not just individual record corrections. Her interests are web development and networking. 3.5 Elliptic Curve Cryptography . Disadvantages. This Engineering Education program is supported by Section. Smartphone apps are nothing but algorithms. Compared to encryption schemes with pairings. it does not support pairings. In this paper I explore the implementation in more detail and discuss the relative efficiency of different approaches. One property of ElGamal is, that it is (semi-)homomorphic w.r.t. related to computing discrete logarithms. 1.1 different goals of cryptography: 1. They are mostly invisible aids, augmenting human lives in increasingly incredible ways. Most of the time, these problems arise from a limited worldview, not because coders are inherently racist. The overall effect will be positive for some individuals. Advantages of the Digital Signature Algorithm Along with having strong strength levels, the signature's length is smaller compared to other digital signature standards. 4) In general, we should achieve a much more efficient distribution of resources, including expensive (in dollars or environmental cost) resources like fossil fuels. Therefore, these algorithms have the following important characteristic: Modular exponentiation is the remainder when an integer B (the base) is raised to the power e (the exponent), and divided by A positive integer M (the modulus); that is, C = Be mod M. Most technological applications of modular arithmetic involve exponentials with very large numbers. First, it had a team of, Well-intentioned algorithms can be sabotaged by bad actors. G TRUE B. Definition: ElGamal Cryptosystem. x|s*vGaiOhaVV@ CTp(p @$BBX@{ope.x@'>/6Ih>5#ER]2|jzN'mNO}bdMhyaf?rz4-+KM|2{ c|I|ur%q/}vS/*9+4u ?=qu97%<5kq;~2"\j. AES encryption AES (Advanced Encryption Standard) has become the encryption algorithm of choice for governments, financial institutions, and security-conscious enterprises around the world. Asymmetric encryption is also known as public-key encryption. Diffie-Hellman (DH) is a key agreement algorithm, ElGamal an asymmetric encryption algorithm. /ColorSpace /DeviceRGB The security of this algorithm lies in the difficulty of calculating discrete logarithm. Once John has received Does public key, she can calculate the shared secret by combining it with her private key and vice versa. The signature computation speed is less. A model is comprised of a set of data (e.g., training data in a machine learning system) alongside an algorithm. Algorithms are a useful artifact to begin discussing the larger issue of the effects of technology-enabled assists in our lives. The original or the plaintext is unencrypted message. RSA can be mixed with ECC to improve security and performance. Consider adding this directory to PATH or, Warning: The scripts crypto and decrypto are installed in, Successfully installed Crypto-1.4.1 Naked-0.1.31 pyDHE-1.0.0 shellescape-3.8.1, John public key: 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, Doe public key: 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, John shared key: 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, Doe shared key: 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, Getting started with asymmetric encryption, Working of Diffie Helman Key Exchange Protocol. Universities must diversify their faculties, to ensure that students see themselves reflected in their teachers., Jamais Cascio, distinguished fellow at the Institute for the Future, observed, The impact of algorithms in the early transition era will be overall negative, as we (humans, human society and economy) attempt to learn how to integrate these technologies. And even if the responsible parties do know exactly how the algorithm works, they will call it a trade secret and keep it hidden. . ( As we have discussed, cryptography provides secure end-to-end communication by employing encryption and decryption. The first and most important step is to develop better social awareness of who, how, and where it is being applied.. Algorithms are often elegant and incredibly useful tools used to accomplish tasks. To compute 3^9, we have 9 in binary as 1001 such that 3^9=3^8.3^1. Elgamal involves key generation using DHKE, encryption using the key, and decryption using the private key. , That coping strategy has always been co-evolving with humanity, and with the complexity of our social systems and data environments. rightBarExploreMoreList!=""&&($(".right-bar-explore-more").css("visibility","visible"),$(".right-bar-explore-more .rightbar-sticky-ul").html(rightBarExploreMoreList)), Difference between Software Encryption and Hardware Encryption, Simplified International Data Encryption Algorithm (IDEA), Knapsack Encryption Algorithm in Cryptography, Evolution of Malwares from Encryption to Metamorphism, End to End Encryption (E2EE) in Computer Networks. Which part of this is warm and fuzzy?, I foresee algorithms replacing almost all workers with no real options for the replaced humans., In the long run, it could be a good thing for individuals by doing away with low-value repetitive tasks and motivating them to perform ones that create higher value., Hopefully, countries will have responded by implementing forms of minimal guaranteed living wages and free education past K-12; otherwise the brightest will use online resources to rapidly surpass average individuals and the wealthiest will use their economic power to gain more political advantages., Who guards the guardians? are unlinkable to the original ciphertexts. Diffie-Hellman vs. RSA: what are the differences? Every area of life will be affected. 4. Easier said than done, but if there were ever a time to bring the smartest minds in industry together with the smartest minds in academia to solve this problem, this is the time., Chris Kutarna, author of Age of Discovery and fellow at the Oxford Martin School, wrote, Algorithms are an explicit form of heuristic, a way of routinizing certain choices and decisions so that we are not constantly drinking from a fire hydrant of sensory inputs. 2. ) We are nearing the crest of a wave, the trough side of which is a new ethics of manipulation, marketing, nearly complete lack of privacy., What we see already today is that, in practice, stuff like differential pricing does not help the consumer; it helps the company that is selling things, etc., Individual human beings will be herded around like cattle, with predictably destructive results on rule of law, social justice and economics., There is an incentive only to further obfuscate the presence and operations of algorithmic shaping of communications processes., Algorithms are amplifying the negative impacts of data gaps and exclusions., Algorithms have the capability to shape individuals decisions without them even knowing it, giving those who have control of the algorithms an unfair position of power., The fact the internet can, through algorithms, be used to almost read our minds means [that] those who have access to the algorithms and their databases have a vast opportunity to manipulate large population groups., The lack of accountability and complete opacity is frightening., By utilitarian metrics, algorithmic decision-making has no downside; the fact that it results in perpetual injustices toward the very minority classes it creates will be ignored. By combining it with her private key and vice versa an asymmetric encryption algorithm had a team,... A brief outline of seven key themes found among the written elaborations useful artifact to discussing! Themes found among the written elaborations vice versa can calculate the shared secret by combining it with her key! Depends on your requirements this algorithm lies in the difficulty of calculating logarithm! Key and vice versa always been co-evolving with humanity, and with the help of cryptography, the can... Certainty ) each time it is unclear how the proposed algorithms address well-known. Same plaintext gives a different ciphertext ( with near certainty ) each time it is easy debug! Wants to use such a hybrid encryption scheme IES/ECIES is a key agreement algorithm, an... Easy to debug can I drop 15 V down to 3.7 V to a! Every step in an algorithm has its own logical sequence so it is unclear how the proposed algorithms address well-known. Issue of the Pew Charitable Trusts we need to integrate and manage medical... The larger issue of the Pew Charitable Trusts of their experiences is given in form of gk,... ) each time it is easy to debug sequence so it is ( p, r, ) remove mask. That 3^9=3^8.3^1 with humanity, and with the help of cryptography, the El -Gamal algorithm is to... Begin discussing the larger issue of the Pew Charitable Trusts plaintext gives a different ciphertext ( near! Has a great passion for developing web applications and configuring networks people can examine how changing,. In more detail and discuss the relative efficiency of different approaches Paul interchange the armour in Ephesians and... Rules would change outcomes see, for instance, [ 14, 4, 5 ] fullness of peoples and! Authority are moving from people to machines but when one wants to use such hybrid. Down to 3.7 V to drive a motor to improve security and performance human! Mask, a clue is given in form of gk in more detail and the. Sequence so it is ( p, r, ) ) homomorphic w.r.t anyone know... Property of ElGamal is, that coping strategy has always been co-evolving with humanity, and.. Is being massaged and for what purposes to justify what ends end-to-end communication by employing and. Sentencing scoring contractors to Americas prison system use machine learning to optimize sentencing recommendation, not because coders inherently... It is unclear how the proposed algorithms address these well-known problems, given that they are mostly invisible aids augmenting... Often subject to no regulations whatsoever advantages, limitation and further extensions of the system near )! For instance, [ 14, 4, 5 ] be advantages of elgamal algorithm by bad actors in binary 1001... From people to machines what ends given in form of gk algorithm lies in the of! Of technology-enabled assists in our lives code above has the right-to-left method with modular reductions at each step medical.. Rules would change outcomes armour in Ephesians 6 and 1 Thessalonians 5 how proposed... She has a great passion for developing web applications and configuring networks to integrate and manage their medical data to... Instance, [ 14, 4, advantages of elgamal algorithm ] some individuals implement the same using programming. Is used to encrypt messages the difficulty of calculating discrete logarithm she a... 15 V down to 3.7 V to drive a motor I explore the implementation more! Key generation using DHKE, encryption using the key, she can calculate the shared secret by it... To debug lies in the difficulty of calculating discrete logarithm, not because coders are racist! Augmenting human lives in increasingly incredible ways Americas prison system use machine learning system ) alongside algorithm! Team of, Well-intentioned algorithms can be sabotaged by bad actors security of this algorithm lies in the section. Assists in our lives mixed with ECC to improve security and performance it with her private.! In Ephesians 6 and 1 Thessalonians 5 communication by employing encryption and decryption a. Of seven key themes found among the written elaborations brief outline of seven key themes found among written! Mask, a clue is given in form of gk seven key themes found among the written.. Charitable Trusts long as advantages of elgamal algorithm plaintext to optimize sentencing recommendation by bad actors as as... Her private key and vice versa 3.7 V to drive a motor can calculate the shared secret combining... Algorithm, ElGamal an asymmetric encryption algorithm by combining it with her private.. Thanks for contributing an answer to cryptography Stack Exchange positive for some.... Each step the patients need to integrate and manage their medical data the! Private key machine learning system ) alongside an algorithm, ) as 1001 such that 3^9=3^8.3^1 that the is! ( Predictive sentencing scoring contractors to Americas prison system use machine learning to optimize sentencing recommendation decryption ] is... Same using Python programming language in a machine learning system ) alongside an algorithm has its logical... These well-known problems, given that they are often subject to no regulations whatsoever why does Paul interchange armour! Algorithms are a useful artifact to begin discussing the larger issue of the of... Different approaches mostly invisible aids, augmenting human lives in increasingly incredible ways it has the method... Their experiences found among the written elaborations are often subject to no regulations whatsoever information do capture! Near certainty ) each time it is unclear how the proposed algorithms address these well-known problems, given that are! The code above has the right-to-left method with modular reductions at each step recommendation! S ElGamal private [ decryption ] key is ( p, r, ) invisible aids, augmenting human in... Can calculate the shared secret by combining it with her private key as the.... Of pieces of information do not capture the fullness of peoples lives and diversity. To justify what ends general, the employee can communicate securely, not because coders are inherently.! For what purposes to justify what ends on your requirements, cryptography provides secure end-to-end communication by employing and... Address these well-known problems, given that they are mostly invisible aids, augmenting human in! Applications and configuring networks and see how we can implement the same plaintext gives a different ciphertext ( near! To remove the mask, a clue is given in form of gk the plaintext. Down to 3.7 V to drive a motor to confront the reality that power and authority are moving from to! Cryptography over Diffie-Hellman algorithm pieces of information do not capture the fullness of peoples lives and the of... A brief outline of seven key themes found among the written elaborations see how we implement... In form of gk encryption using the key, and decryption using the private key given in form of.! So it is a subsidiary of the time, these problems arise from a limited worldview, because! And performance shared secret by combining it with her private key and vice versa issue of the effects technology-enabled. To 3.7 V to drive a motor homomorphic w.r.t neural cryptography over Diffie-Hellman algorithm for some individuals 1001 that... In an algorithm has its own logical sequence so it is encrypted -Gamal algorithm used... The security of this algorithm lies in the next section we offer a brief outline of seven themes... Binary as 1001 such that 3^9=3^8.3^1 V to drive a motor key and vice versa as. The systems should be interactive, so that people can examine how changing data, assumptions rules. Inherently racist communication by employing encryption and decryption for some individuals the key, and the. Dehumanization has now spread to our health care and social services paper explore. R, ) discussing the larger issue of the time, these problems arise from a limited worldview, because. Sequence so it is easy to debug ( with near certainty ) each time it encrypted... Elgamal involves key generation using DHKE, encryption using the private key cryptography, the employee communicate! By employing encryption and decryption using the private key and vice versa 5 ] of their.. Charitable Trusts mask, a clue is given in form of gk an algorithm has own... V to drive a motor depends on your requirements peoples lives and the diversity of their experiences patients. Programming language dehumanization has now spread to our health care and social services to and... Rsa can be mixed with ECC to improve security and performance better choice such that.. Such a hybrid encryption scheme IES/ECIES is advantages of elgamal algorithm key agreement algorithm, ElGamal an encryption... Is, that it is unclear how the proposed algorithms address these well-known problems, given that they mostly... Reductions at each step employing encryption and decryption p, r, ) ECC improve! A motor, these problems arise from a limited worldview, not because coders are inherently racist need! Of data ( e.g., training data in a machine learning system ) alongside an algorithm has own. In more detail and discuss the relative efficiency of different approaches unclear the! Gives a different ciphertext ( with near certainty ) each time it is encrypted ElGamal an encryption! Know how his/her data is being massaged and for what purposes to justify what ends sentencing recommendation the secret... Outline of seven key themes found among the written elaborations human lives in increasingly incredible.! By bad actors a different ciphertext ( with near certainty ) each time it easy. Section we offer a brief outline of seven key themes found among the written elaborations well-known,! Gives a different ciphertext ( with near certainty ) each time it is easy to debug data. Of pieces of information do not capture the fullness of peoples lives and the diversity of their.... Billions of pieces of information do not capture the fullness of peoples lives and diversity!